Society & Culture

Why don’t Iranians Trust Each Other?

March 5, 2014
Shima Shahrabi
5 min read
Why don’t Iranians Trust Each Other?
Why don’t Iranians Trust Each Other?

I am sitting in the lobby of one the biggest hotels in Houston, Texas, the owner of which is an Iranian-American. I have filled out employment papers and now I am waiting for a face-to-face interview. I am thinking: an Iranian boss is sure to hire other Iranians. My illusion is shattered, however, the moment I enter Mr. R.D.’s office. “I am not very eager to work with Iranians,” he tells me in English.

The hotel’s employees are not allowed to speak to each other in Persian. “None of my top managers is Iranian,” he continues, “because I don’t like the Iranian style of management. We can talk about a job if you have worked with American managers.”

R.D. believes that there are two types of Iranian managers: those who think management is about being a taskmaster and treat the employees too harshly, and those who become lazy the moment they become managers and sit on their behinds.

“Unfortunately,” he says, referring to his 20 years’ worth of experience, “whenever I have trusted Iranians, everything has gone wrong. I have promised myself to only hire Iranians for less senior jobs and give the high-level jobs to Americans.”

R.D. is not the only employer who is less than keen to work with Iranians. Through interviewing other Iranian employers, I discover that many of them share the same view, albeit for different reasons. One example is Farhad, who owns a sandwich shop in Los Angeles. “Iranians are not as agile as Mexicans,” he explains. “The work of a Mexican in the restaurant is equal to the work of two Iranians. Mexicans are stronger because they have been raised to do farm work from childhood, so it does not pay to replace Mexican workers with Iranians.”

Now I understand why the food in Iranian-American restaurants does not taste genuine. This is what one must expect when a Mexican cook prepares an Iranian dish!

A Two-Way Street

This reluctance to work with other Iranian immigrants is, of course, a two-way street. In my experience, Iranian job seekers in the US prefer to work for American employers. “Iranian employers always offer the lowest salary,” says a man called Farid. “They work you to death and their management style is ugly.”

“Iranians have their own rules that make it very difficult to work with them,” says Sara, who recently arrived to the US and is still working towards improving her English. She works at an Iranian restaurant but is looking for a job at a restaurant that is not managed by an Iranian. “In all American restaurants, the tip is for the waiter, but here, the restaurant owner does not pass on the tips to us. He says ‘I told you from the start that your pay would be $8 per hour. I did not say anything about tips.’ Even if somebody tips us in cash, we have to drop it into a jar next to the cash register.”

A Comparison of Immigrant Communities

This mistrust becomes more pronounced when you compare the Iranian experience with that of other immigrants. In Indian beauty salons you do not see many Mexican, Anglo-American or Iranian hairdressers. In most Chinese shops, you see employees of Chinese or East Asian descent. In Mexican restaurants, most employees speak Spanish. In Iranian shops or restaurants, however, often the people running the business are of Chinese, Mexican or Indian descent. They are not people originating from Iran.

Poor relations among Iranian immigrants do not only affect work environments. According to Dr. Bizhan Bandari, a dermatologist and a professor at the University of California Los Angeles, even in academic environments, the trust normally seen between immigrants is absent from the Iranian community. Any doctor entering the U.S. to work “must pass the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) to be able to practice medicine in America,” he says. “Every year the highest grades go to Indians.” He says this is not because they are more intelligent or more knowledgeable than other groups entering the country, but “because of their solidarity”. They support one another in their attempts to work in the U.S., and have created a database of useful and important questions that they share among one another. “Iranians hide everything from each other,” he says, and the lack of trust among Iranian students is stands out. “For example, they don’t tell each other that they are taking tests, conceal their grades and don’t reveal their study programs.”

A History of Secrecy?

“I am sorry to say that subterfuge has become part of our culture. Distrust becomes the norm when subterfuge becomes pervasive in a society,” observes Dr. Asghar Mohajeri, sociologist and college professor. It “leads to a habit of secrecy” and secrecy leads to lies. People are one thing but pretend to be another, he adds. The result is hypocrisy – and, in his opinion, there is a deep-rooted tradition of hypocrisy in Iranian culture. He turns to the great poet Hafez for proof:

“Preachers, shining so brightly on stage/In private, other deeds they engage.”

“Lies, hypocrisy, secrecy and subterfuge are the enemies of trust,” he adds. “Take away the trust and solidarity has no chance. Immigrants are more cynical because they were fed up with those things and left. They are searching for a utopia and naturally want to keep their distance from their compatriots.”

Telling lies has become a part of Iranian society, says university professor and sociologist Amanollah Gharaii Moghaddam.  And it’s increasing at “an alarming rate, especially over the past century” and has taken root across the social divide and in all classes. “Imagine the problems that arise when two members of one family don’t trust each other,” Moghaddam adds. Then extend it to the society at large. The robustness of that society will become “seriously jeopardized”, and corruption threatens to “contaminate all social, economic and political institutions”.

“Of course, Iranian authorities make the problem worse,” he adds. “When they make promises that they don’t keep, public trust is weakened and mistrust spreads. A society and its individual cannot be separated. Mistrust among people, even among spouses, has its roots in society.”

“In Iranian society, the gap between words and actions is too wide, so individuals keep their distance from each other and prefer foreigners.” Iranian expatriates, he concludes, “have grown up in a society devoid of trust”, so it is “only logical” that they would prefer to spend their time with people who are not Iranian. 

comments

us_soldier27
February 5, 2015

...continuing from the last post

I talked to some of the other employees there. And truth be told, he had a reputation of doing this, no one there had predictable work schedules, and he would relentlessly burn out new-hires with exactly the sort of routine he wanted out of me. I understand some sleep-deprivat ion is just business, but with a near hour commute, icy and dangerous roads, nothing but 3 to 4 hours of sleep is just dangerous. Staying awake and alert is just commonsense. I have no idea how he even expected that to fly with me, let alone anyone else. When I tried to reason this out with him, he pulled some of the classic Iranian management lines, similar to how you lay it out: "But I need you to do it" When I asked why similar wasn't being ask from other employees, or how he expected me to learn the job on three hours of sleep he just said, "Oh I don't know". What I suspect was, was that he expected me to not have my previous job ready, and that he thought he had me at 100% vulnerability. Just so, when I left my previous job, he could slap me with something as bad if not worse than the other one. Needless to say, I just quit, called up my old employer, and got told my old job is still there (with only a few days of separation, and I left on good terms).

I could write a book about similar circumstances. Persians have been extremely difficult to reason with though, so I'm glad your post shows an open mind. Either I get boo-ed away as being "racist" (even though I had nothing racial to say, and I'm not white), or "you don't understand", or some other trope. But nearly every story I've ever heard about Iranian managers has all been like this. They think they are being business savvy by focusing so heavily on the numbers, its always about the numbers, that they end up burning their employees alive with shennigans like this, or they end up frustrating customers, or both. One friend I had (who was also a young Iranian, not coincidentally) told me a similar bizarre and disapppointing story. Her dad ended up dying of a heart attack, she took a week's vacation time to go to his funeral, told her employer about it all in advance...only to come back to find her job got taken, and she had gotten fired while she was gone. TO GO TO HER FATHERS FUNERAL! And, with the restaurant manager being Iranian, you would think he could have had a heart for her, but no. And this only scratches the surface.

So, I really don't understand. But you mention that Iranians are secretive and mistrustful, I don't understand why, in these cases. There aren't any evil regimes, or fanatics, or anything like that here. They all had the virtues of their own actions, but this is how they acted, lying to me about the job in one case, out right stabbing one of their own countrymen in the back in the other. Why does it have to be this way?
... read more

us_soldier27
February 5, 2015

Why does it have to be that way though?

us_soldier27
February 5, 2015

Salam, Omidvaram ke haletoon khoobe,

Hey there, I saw your post, so I couldn't help but to respond. Let me make a few disclaimers:

1. I'm not Iranian, I'm hispanic (I look Iranian, but I'm not from the region)
2. I have a basic grasp of the language and grammar. Not enough to dec lare fluency, but enough to get by.
3. I have tons of experience with Persians, (and Afghans), but I'm often left with more questions than answers

Recently, I had an experience that fits your post. I was working at a local grocery store, and an Iranian manager at a gas station, who I knew from friends and because he shopped there on occasion told me about a job opening at his gas station. Long story short about my previous job, for most circumstances it was alright, but as a full-time accounting student, the sort of hours I was getting was reaching the point of becoming unmanageable. But, when he (the Iranian guy) had said there was an opening, I thought, why not. I believe in giving people chances.

He absolutely PROMISED his job would be easier in terms of manageable hours. He understood my educational commitments, commute, and so on, and would be flexible to that. He just stipulated that he wanted someone that could open and or close his gas station. I'm not against either, rather, all I demanded when I meant by manageable hours were hours that did not needlessly take away study time.

There were warning signs he gave me that showed he was being deceitful, exactly like how you posted. He's smiles and warmth didn't seem geninue all the time, he absolutely insisted I give my two weeks before he would really 'show me' things, and so on. But again- I believe in giving people chances.

Well, on the final day of my two week notice at the grocery store, he gave me my new one week schedule. I couldn't believe how insane it was, even now I'm shocked at how he thought this was even ok. He absolutely expected me to close his store, then open, then close again, all week straight. This would amount to basically 3 to 4 hours of sleep a night, every day, for the next week. And no telling how long it would continue. Suffice to say I'm glad I left my previous job on good graces and I can go back. But when we were negotiating for the job, his one selling point was that he was going to be easier on hours...so to wait out my two weeks at the previous job, JUST To slap me with something as positively ridiculous as this, just flabbergasted me.
... read more

Speaking of Iran

Iranian Traders Boycott Malaysian Goods Over Umno’s Anti-Shia Campaign

March 5, 2014
Speaking of Iran
Why don’t Iranians Trust Each Other?